Metal vs. Shingles: What’s the Best Roof for Your Virginia Home?

We get it. As roofers serving Harrisonburg, Staunton, Waynesboro, and homes across Augusta County, we hear this question around the kitchen table all the time. And the truth is — there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

Let’s walk through the real pros and cons of each, so you can feel confident when it’s time to choose.

If you want a roof you won’t have to think about for decades, metal is a solid bet. A standing seam metal roof can last 40–70 years. It’s tough against wind, hail, snow, and even fire — which matters with the weather swings we get in Central Virginia.

Asphalt shingles usually last 20–30 years, depending on the quality and maintenance. They’re sturdy, but more prone to wear and tear over time, especially after repeated storms or sun exposure.

• Shingles are typically less expensive upfront, making them a great choice for homeowners on a tighter budget or those planning to move within 10 years.
• Energy Efficiency: Shingles, especially darker ones, tend to absorb heat — but new technologies in premium shingles are helping improve this (we’ll get to that in a second)

• Metal roofing comes with a higher initial price, but fewer repair needs and longer life mean it often pays for itself in the long ru
• Energy Efficiency: Which Roof Keeps You Cooler? Metal roofs reflect sunlight and reduce heat absorption, which helps keep your attic (and electric bill) cooler in the summer.

Shingles: Come in a variety of colors and textures, blending beautifully with most home styles — whether you have a rancher in Waynesboro or a historic two-story in Staunton.

Metal: Delivers a clean, bold look that fits both modern and farmhouse aesthetics. It also comes in different panel styles and colors, offering more design flexibility than most people expect.

Shingle roofs may need the occasional repair after storms or years of wear, especially if they weren’t installed properly. Metal roofs require less maintenance overall and hold up longer without patchwork — though denting from severe hail is still possible.

🏠 Need a checkup or patch? We’ve got you covered with reliable roof repairs.

So here’s where things get really interesting — because not all shingle roofs are created equal.

At Baber Enterprises, we install the GAF TimberSteel™ Roofing System — a premium metal shingle solution that bridges the gap between traditional shingles and metal roofing.

Why TimberSteel™ Stands Out:

• Built to last with multi-layer durability and industry-leading wind resistance
• LayerLock™ technology helps seal out wind-driven rain and protect against blow-off
• StainGuard® Plus keeps your roof looking clean and streak-free
• Architectural style for eye-catching depth and curb appeal
• Backed by GAF’s Limited Lifetime Warranty

Think of TimberSteel™ as the “luxury SUV crossover" of asphalt and metal— stylish, tough, and ready for whatever Virginia weather throws your way.

It's the go-to choice for many of our clients who want the protection of metal roofing with the familiar look of shingles.

🔨 So… What’s Right for You?

Want a long-lasting, low-maintenance roof with bold looks?

👉 Go metal.

Looking for a trusted, affordable option that still performs well?

👉 Shingles are a smart pick.

Want the best of both worlds — top-tier performance with architectural curb appeal?

👉 Consider GAF TimberSteel™.

Whatever your situation, we’ll help you figure out what fits your home, your goals, and your budget.

📞 Let’s Chat About Your Roof

Whether you're ready to schedule or just want honest advice, the team at Baber Enterprises Roofing and More is here to help. We’ve been roofing in the Valley for three generations, and we treat your home like it’s our own.

✅ Free inspections

✅ Expert guidance

✅ Local crew. No pressure.

👉 Contact us today ›